Verified Trading Signals

Original signal identifiers and coverage denominators

Detect duplicated, missing and unexpected IDs before calculating declared proof and execution subsets.

Editorial revision: 14 October 2026

Evidence methods, not a provider certification. Authored examples and user-entered check states are not independently verified trading results.

Freeze the original roster

The denominator for a complete-history assertion begins with a named offer, source version and period. Its original stable IDs need to be recorded before proof availability or outcome is examined. A reviewer cannot define the denominator as the files that happen to be present in the supplied archive. That makes the missing records disappear by construction and can conceal selective disclosure.

The ID checker accepts an explicit original roster and a separate record array. IDs are bounded, case-sensitive ASCII labels; the teaching syntax is not a claim about any provider's production IDs. The roster must be unique and nonempty. Record rows can contain duplicates or unexpected IDs so the tool can report those discrepancies rather than silently discard them. Exact identity reconciliation is separate from validating the contents of each row.

Equal totals can still hide missing records

The packet contains eight original IDs and eight base record rows. Its discrepancy variant keeps eight rows but substitutes another S002 row for S007. A count-only reconciliation returns the same row total. The ID checker reports duplicate S002 and missing S007, retires complete-population percentages and retains the observed row states for inspection. It does not choose which duplicate to keep.

Another variant adds S999, which is outside the frozen original roster. That extra row cannot increase proof coverage for the declared population. A third variant removes an original record entirely. These cases demonstrate why row count, unique-ID count and original-ID membership need separate fields. They are software and reasoning exercises, not a real archive of provider omissions or a fabricated misconduct dataset.

Coverage has several subsets

In the reconciled invented base, six of eight records have commitment labels and six have proof-file labels. Three carry declared successful-check labels, while three carry execution-record labels. Their intersection is one original ID. Each count has a different meaning. A proof-file label is not a completed check, an execution-record label is not a reviewed fill and the intersection does not establish a profitable trade.

The checker exports exact numerator and denominator pairs instead of inventing a confidence score. A proof state of declared_pass requires both commitment and proof-file labels in this schema, but that consistency requirement does not authenticate them. Pending, declared_fail, unperformed and missing stay separate. If identity reconciliation fails, ratios are null rather than calculated over a quietly repaired denominator.

Keep terminal states explicit

Original instructions can be closed winners, closed losers, flat, open, unfilled, cancelled before a fill or unresolved. The practice packet has two labelled winners, one loser and one flat among four closed records. Its closed-only fraction is two of four under the declared inclusion rule. It says nothing about the economic value or complete-account return of the fictional population.

A cancellation after a fill cannot be treated as a pre-fill cancellation that erases the position. Actual quantities, fees and open exposure require economic records. A count-only row can preserve that question without answering it. The new ID checker does not calculate returns; the original worksheet remains available for declared totals, with its safe-integer and subset guards intact. Their different outputs should not be marketed as a provider score.

Release the unresolved-ID map

A useful coverage result lists missing IDs, repeated identities and unexpected rows beside each declared subset. Keep the source roster and record array together so another reviewer can reproduce the membership comparison. If the period population is not independently established, describe it as the declared population even when the rows reconcile perfectly. A mathematically complete table cannot authenticate its own inclusion policy.

Use the archive-export guide to retain versions and lawful access constraints. A future real review would need original artifacts and verification transcripts, not the invented packet labels. The purpose of exact ID comparison is to expose bookkeeping gaps before broader claims are made. Reconciliation can make evidence easier to inspect without establishing the truth of a proof, the identity of an author or the profitability of a trading service.

Mechanism and source references

Mechanism references are not provider certifications. The new editorial examples are authored exercises; no independent financial review was performed.

Inspect the working packet

Eight originals, four discrepancy variants and six chronology cases